Select your language

Air conditioning in clean rooms and pharmaceutical laboratories (III)

Third and final part of this special. This time we will delve into the topic of forgotten design criteria in HVAC projects.

by Eng. María Lucía Botero N*

HVAC design processes often become mechanical: CT C, technology selection, equipment selection, duct design, piping, control and budget.
But sometimes what can cause the failure of the project? When I say failure I mean that a computer operates incorrectly, that the conditions are not achieved, that control fails, that the client does not maintain the equipment properly, etc.

Well, here I am going to present a summary of some of those points that are left forgotten in the day to day of design, all to leave one project and move on to the next as quickly as possible.
The project must be born with the understanding of its raison d'être and believe me, it is not always just about air conditioning an area, it is not so, there are many underlying reasons: the stability of a product, the operation and useful life of an electronic equipment, the success of a pharmaceutical, medical procedure; the preservation of a life using air conditioning in hospitals in critical areas and drug production. It seems logical, but in my concept it often fails from this first step: that of conceptualizing why the project was born.

- Publicidad -

The process of calculating thermal load continues. Yes, there are excellent calculation software, there are regulations that are clear guides for a design, almost one could say that they are the navigation chart and if some variations are not made, nothing will happen. There is also LEED certification, which gives the project a class of maximum energy saving. But what if we use all these valuable tools and do not stop to review small details that repeatedly cause projects to fail.
Now then I will mention some of these details:

1. What is the simultaneity of use of the system? By this I mean how the operation will be given, whether to partial loads and / or total loads or failing that both. This is often one of the most difficult problems to attack, because once the equipment is purchased there is no going back. And it is that the decision of the size of the system is made because it becomes common to repeat which is the most efficient system in "tables of selections", but what is the operation in real life? Did you analyze if it is useful for your client to have on paper the most efficient equipment in history, but it turns out that it was not operating at its best point of efficiency?

2. Technology selection: Although this point is highly linked to the previous one, they complement each other widely. Well, what happens here: it is necessary to make an analysis of a number of questions that we must ask ourselves, after determining the thermal load and simultaneity, where particularly many of the answers will be delivered from different areas of the client, then some of them: Does the client already have a technology installed? How has your experience been? Are you happy with the current provider or want to switch? What process do you have of maintenance, spare parts or contingency in case of failure? What budget does the project have?

And something that seems basic, but it is not, is to question the location or the ease of monitoring the project and linking it to know if it will have a stand alone control system or with the possibility of remote monitoring. Well, with those questions and many others, many failures can be avoided in the future. Examples:

A. Choose a variable refrigerant system and not have the trained personnel and / or response of the supplier.

B. Choose cold water systems condensed by water, because they are more efficient and the client does not know, nor does he have the slightest idea of keeping the tower water circuit in optimal conditions, which makes it useless to be in numbers a more efficient system because in the operation it will be the opposite.

C. Consider that the entire project should have the same technology, when there are areas that work at different times than the central system and redundancy was not thought of.

- Publicidad -

3. Location of equipment: this is not an easy task because it is often the struggle with architectural design, but it is there where we must be smart and achieve a negotiation with the client so that tomorrow the refrigeration technicians do not hate the consultants. How is it possible that we leave installed equipment where not even a 5-year-old child accesses? And the implications are not only maintenance, but the possibility of inspection and incorrect operation. But there are other proposals that worry me even more and are cases such as, for example, seeing a discharge to the outside of a room works in negative pressure next to a handling unit for a clean area of maximum classification.

One would think that it does not have to come in any norm because it should only be taken into account by common sense. An example for the hospital sector would be a discharge from a room of insulated next to the outside air intake of an operating room. That is why I return to the same point: there can be standards of all kinds and projects end up with your plate at the entrance of your certification process; but if this happens in the technical rooms where 95% or more have no idea that this is happening, nothing will be achieved.

4. Control system: It is a fact that already today the percentage of projects are accompanied by a control system even if it is basic, but sometimes I wonder if it is worth all that investment. Are these systems used 100% and maintained over time? For me the answer is no. You can make stunning control diagrams and sequences with great detail, but in many cases, running with luck, they work at the time of the inauguration because many times they do not work there and so they stay.

My point in this item is that you must also go through a process of identifying with the client in reality about what you want to control and what you want to monitor, so that tomorrow you do not see buried investments that will simply be "puentiadas", marking an erroneous measurement, or the saddest, with all the correct information but that absolutely nobody uses it.
Surely there will be more criteria that pass me by... the reflection for all of us consultants is to stop making the designs as if they were an online production, and spend more time analyzing, as we say, "putting ourselves on the client's shirt".

In summary, one could say that pharmaceutical laboratories, because they have in most cases defined parameters to fully comply with (temperature, HR, changes per hour, pressures, etc.); they should be supremely easy to design and there should be no flaws. However, reflection is to further study certain criteria that can be fundamental to the success of the project and are often left forgotten.

* María Lucía Botero N, is an engineer at Camilo Botero Ingenieros Asociados, you can write to the email: [email protected]

Duván Chaverra Agudelo
Duván Chaverra AgudeloEmail: [email protected]
Editor Jefe
Jefe Editorial en Latin Press, Inc,. Comunicador Social y Periodista con experiencia de más de 12 años en medios de comunicación. Apasionado por la tecnología. Director Académico del Congreso RefriAméricas.

No comments

• If you're already registered, please log in first. Your email will not be published.

Leave your comment

In reply to Some User
Building Automation Days 2025 in Bogota marks a milestone for the KNX standard in Latin America

Building Automation Days 2025 in Bogota marks a milestone for the KNX standard in Latin America

Colombia. With more than a hundred attendees and the participation of six high-profile exhibitors, Building Automation Days by KNX LATAM, Colombia edition, established itself as the most relevant...

Design Envelope Technology Hits 750 gpm Fire Pump Segment

Design Envelope Technology Hits 750 gpm Fire Pump Segment

Canada. In response to the growing demands of the fire protection industry, Armstrong Fluid Technology announced the expansion of its Vertical-In-Line pump line with the addition of the new 5x4x10PF...

Greenheck Launches New RV-220 Model and Expands Its Line of Dedicated Outdoor Air Systems

Greenheck Launches New RV-220 Model and Expands Its Line of Dedicated Outdoor Air Systems

United States. Greenheck announced the addition of the RV-220 to its line of dedicated outdoor air systems (DOAS), a solution that responds to the growing demand for equipment with greater outdoor...

Embraco enters the HVAC market with new scroll compressors and aims to become a full-service supplier

Embraco enters the HVAC market with new scroll compressors and aims to become a full-service supplier

Brazil. Embraco announced its official entry into the heating, ventilation and air conditioning (HVAC) market following the acquisition of the specialized company Xecom, and the launch of a new line...

SIGMAN GROUP and Carrier-VRF reinforce technical training in the HVAC sector in Ecuador

SIGMAN GROUP and Carrier-VRF reinforce technical training in the HVAC sector in Ecuador

Ecuador. An intensive week of technical and commercial training brought together key players in the HVAC sector in Quito and Guayaquil, thanks to the joint initiative of GRUPO SIGMAN and...

AHR Expo Mexico 2025 returns to Monterrey with its most ambitious edition yet

AHR Expo Mexico 2025 returns to Monterrey with its most ambitious edition yet

Mexico. The event returns this year to Monterrey with an unprecedented edition. The exhibition, dedicated to air conditioning, ventilation, heating, refrigeration and filtration solutions, promises...

Fujitsu Launches New AIRSTAGE Multi-Position Air Handler with R-32 Refrigerant

Fujitsu Launches New AIRSTAGE Multi-Position Air Handler with R-32 Refrigerant

United States. Fujitsu General America announced the launch of its new AIRSTAGE Multi-Position Air Handling Unit (MPAHU), designed to provide greater application flexibility by easily...

HVAC project at the Javeriana University, finalist in the CALA Awards 2025 in the HVAC category

HVAC project at the Javeriana University, finalist in the CALA Awards 2025 in the HVAC category

The HVAC system installed in the building of the Faculty of Sciences of the Pontificia Universidad Javeriana, in Bogotá, was selected as a finalist in the HVAC category of the CALA Awards 2025. The...

Concord Project in La Lima Free Trade Zone, finalist in the HVAC category of the CALA Awards 2025

Concord Project in La Lima Free Trade Zone, finalist in the HVAC category of the CALA Awards 2025

The HVAC system project carried out by MultiFRIO for the company Concord in the La Lima Free Trade Zone, in Cartago, received the final prize in the HVAC category of the CALA Awards 2025, a...

HVAC project at the Universidad Santiago de Cali, finalist in the CALA AWARDS HVAC category

HVAC project at the Universidad Santiago de Cali, finalist in the CALA AWARDS HVAC category

The air conditioning project of the Auditorium Building and the Technology Center of the new campus of the Santiago de Cali University was chosen as a finalist in the HVAC category of the CALA...

Free Subscription
Remember Me
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER
DO YOU NEED A SERVICE OR PRODUCT QUOTE?
LASTEST INTERVIEWS
SITE SPONSORS










LASTEST NEWSLETTER
Ultimo Info-Boletin