Select your language

Comparison of refrigeration systems for a commercial application

Comparación de sistemas de refrigeración para una aplicación comercial

Energy efficiency plays a preponderant role in this class of sectors.

by Rafael H Rau V.*

The study shows that improved Transcritical and Subcritical CO2 systems can achieve energy efficiencies, and, cost of living and final cost to users superior to solutions with other refrigerants commonly used in these applications.

The efficiency comparison was made using the specific climate of the location, with a record of 20 years, and the analysis of the climate of the last 10 years, given the influence of current climate change.

- Publicidad -

The study analyzes the carbon footprint of all proposed systems, on a 20-year basis.

The costs of equipment and facilities are in line with previous experiences in projects of similar capacity.

Inflation and interest benchmarks have been obtained from central bank publications.

The thermal load for the systems is
- Low Temperature System; 47 kW at -30ºC evaporation temperature, OSH
- Medium Temperature System; 195 kW at -8ºC evaporation temperature, OSH

For the purposes of the condensation temperature, the climate was analyzed, to determine the temperatures of dry bulb and wet bulb, maximum in the last 20 years, expressed in a period of one year of 8,760 hours.

The R744 (CO2) system will use, according to the climate, an adiabatic evaporative condenser, to work in a subcritical condition; one of the improvement tools used in this cycle.

Systems with Refrigerants: R448a, R404a, will use, in accordance with common practice, in this comparison, air-cooled condensers. A further improvement can be made, making use of the same type of capacitor used for the R744 (CO2).

- Publicidad -

The climate for location, maximum dry bulb and wet bulb temperatures, in degrees Celsius, for a record of 20 years, are as follows:

Figure 1A



Figure 1B

According to the climate, systems with R744 will be operated under subcritical conditions with adiabatic evaporative condensers.

Air-cooled condensers are used for systems with R404a and R449a.

- Publicidad -

The compressors to be used in the systems, their capacities, and, energy consumption are detailed in the following table:

Table 1.
Systems with R404a and R449a refrigerants are conventional systems and share a condenser.

To be competitive, the system with R744 (CO2) must integrate technologies that improve its efficiency, but at the same time increase the cost of the system, in the graph below, the description of the system:


Figure 2.
Pressure diagram – enthalpy

Figure 3.
Pressure diagram table – enthalpy


Table 2.
The BIN analysis, for the three systems, 8760 hours per year, simultaneity factor of 0.82, yields the following, annual energy demand, including capacitors.


Table 3.

The initial cost, installation, maintenance, and, operating costs are evaluated at present value, for a useful life of 15 years, and an effective year-on-year interest rate of 0.49%.


Table 4

The total costs to the owner, which include energy demand, water consumption, external service assistance, maintenance, and including amortization, are as follows:


Table 5.

The carbon footprint of the three systems, for the specific location and its current conversion standards, the accumulated known statistics of leaks, the initial refrigerant charge and refills is evaluated according to the latest data for these refrigerants, for a period of 20 years.


Table 6.

The R744 Cooling System represents, for these conditions, the best option.

For this to be possible it is necessary to use the tools that thermodynamics provides us, make correct use of them from the study of climate of the hydrography of the location, two resources are basic for this; water and energy.

In general cooling systems with R744, so that their efficiency and costs are competitive, an integrated analysis is required, of greater depth, this type of system will not be more efficient by itself, the designer will establish this difference.

On the other hand, it is a natural refrigerant, which will last over time; improvements can still be incorporated into the system, in the same way the Refrigerants R404a and R449a, can incorporate, for example, the same type of condenser used for R744, and in the present study a subcooling of the liquid at the outlet of the condenser equivalent to 15ºC has been used, for these refrigerants.

The significant reduction of the carbon footprint is another of the variables to consider in terms of decision-making in line, with recent studies of the effects of global warming in the short term, the carbon footprint has been calculated for its effect in 20 years, practice recently proposed by the agencies responsible for the area.

* Rafael H Rau V. Refrigeration and Consulting Engineers, S.A. [email protected]

Duván Chaverra Agudelo
Duván Chaverra AgudeloEmail: [email protected]
Jefe Editorial de las revistas AVI Latinoamérica, ACR Latinoamérica, Ventas de Seguridad, Zona de Pinturas, Aftermarket Internation, Gerencia de Edificios, TV y Video, y Director Académico en Latin Press, Inc,.
Comunicador Social y Periodista con experiencia de más de 18 años en medios de comunicación. Apasionado por la tecnología y por esta industria.

No comments

• If you're already registered, please log in first. Your email will not be published.

Leave your comment

In reply to Some User
Register for the Building Automation Webinar: Keys to Understanding Modbus and BACnet

Register for the Building Automation Webinar: Keys to Understanding Modbus and BACnet

International.  On March 27, 2025, ACR Latin America will offer a webinar focused on building automation protocols, with an emphasis on understanding Modbus and BACnet.

Scientists develop the first elastocaloric air conditioner on a commercial scale

Scientists develop the first elastocaloric air conditioner on a commercial scale

International. Researchers at the Hong Kong University of Science and Technology (HKUST) have developed the first elastocaloric air conditioning system with cooling capacity on a commercial scale.

Daikin recognized among the

Daikin recognized among the "Clarivate Top 100 Global Innovators 2025"

International. Daikin Industries has been selected as one of the Clarivate Top 100 Global Innovators 2025, a distinction awarded by Clarivate, a global information services company based in London,...

Condensation Control: A Challenge for HVAC System Efficiency

Condensation Control: A Challenge for HVAC System Efficiency

International. Condensation damp represents a major challenge in the air conditioning of buildings, affecting energy efficiency, indoor air quality and occupant comfort.

Honeywell to Convert Its Refrigerant Business to a Standalone Company: Solstice Advanced Materials

Honeywell to Convert Its Refrigerant Business to a Standalone Company: Solstice Advanced Materials

United States. Honeywell announced that its refrigerant business will be renamed Solstice Advanced Materials as part of its plan to become an independent, publicly traded company in the U.S.

SODECA revolutionizes fire safety with a simulation of its pressurization system

SODECA revolutionizes fire safety with a simulation of its pressurization system

International. SODECA's BOXPDS has surprised with an innovative live demonstration of its evacuation route pressurization system. The system creates a barrier against smoke in just three seconds.

Resideo will invest more than 4.9 million dollars in Aguascalientes to install corporate office

Resideo will invest more than 4.9 million dollars in Aguascalientes to install corporate office

Mexico. The U.S. company Resideo announced an investment of more than 4.9 million dollars (99 million Mexican pesos) to establish a corporate office in Aguascalientes, from where it will provide...

Webinar: Building Automation Protocol: Understanding Modbus and BACnet

Webinar: Building Automation Protocol: Understanding Modbus and BACnet

Topic: Building Automation Protocol Overview: Understanding Modbus and BACnet By: Camilo Olvera, Sales Manager for Mexico Armstrong Fluid Technology Alejandro Hernández, Distribution Manager –...

Six Marketing Trends for HVAC Companies in 2025

Six Marketing Trends for HVAC Companies in 2025

The HVAC industry is in a stage of limitless transformation, driven by technology, sustainability and the evolution of the expectations of all consumers. By Andrea Álvarez*

Mabe to invest $668 million in Mexico through 2027, despite tariffs

Mabe to invest $668 million in Mexico through 2027, despite tariffs

Mexico. The multinational Mabe announced an investment of 668 million dollars in Mexico between 2025 and 2027, regardless of the tariffs imposed by the United States.

Free Subscription
Remember Me
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER
DO YOU NEED A SERVICE OR PRODUCT QUOTE?
LASTEST INTERVIEWS
SITE SPONSORS










LASTEST NEWSLETTER
Ultimo Info-Boletin